GSTAT Jurisdiction Search: How to Determine the Correct Bench for Your Appeal

Blog 9: GSTAT Jurisdiction Search: How to Determine the Correct Bench for Your Appeal

Filing your appeal before the correct bench of the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) is crucial for timely adjudication. Jurisdiction under GSTAT broadly depends on whether the dispute falls within the domain of the Principal Bench or the relevant State Bench under Section 109 of the CGST Act. While appeals in certain specific subject matters go directly before the Principal Bench, for other matters, the jurisdiction of the State Bench will be determined by geographic factors or jurisdiction of the order passed by First Appellate Authority.

Filing before the wrong bench can lead to rejection, delays, limitation risks and additional costs. This comprehensive guide will help you to accurately determine jurisdiction for your GSTAT appeal.

Structure of GSTAT and Jurisdiction of Principal and State Benches

GSTAT operates through a hierarchical structure established under Section 109 of the CGST Act. There will be two types of benches in GSTAT viz: Principal Bench and State Benches:

1. Principal Bench (New Delhi) – The composition of Principal Bench would be as under:

• President of the GSTAT
• One Judicial Member
• One Technical Member (Centre)
• One Technical Member (State)

The Principal Bench is constituted vide Notification S.O. 3048(E), dated July 31, 2024, and located in New Delhi.

2. State Benches– The State Benches are notified vide Notification S.O. 3048(E) dated 31.07.2024. The composition of State Benches would be as under:

• Two Judicial Members with the senior-most Judicial Member functioning as Vice President
• Technical Member (Centre)
• Technical Member (State)

Determining Jurisdiction: A Step-by-Step Approach

Step 1: Identify the Nature of Dispute – Principal bench vs. State bench

The first step in determining jurisdiction is understanding the subject matter of your appeal:

Matters under Principal Bench Jurisdiction under Section 109 of the CGST Act

1. Place of Supply Disputes: If the appeal relates to determination of place of supply or one of the issues in dispute is determination of place of supply, then the jurisdiction to decide such appeal would be with the Principal Bench. Matters involving following issues will be decided by Principal Bench:

• Inter-state vs. intra-state supply determination
• Disputes relating to Sections 10 to 13 of IGST Act

2. Anti-Profiteering Cases

• Appeal against anti-profiteering order

3. Input Service Distributor (ISD) Matters

• Cases involving one or more issues related to manner of distribution of credit by input service distributor provided in Section 20 of the CGST Act.

4. OIDAR and Actionable Claims

• Cases involving one or more issue with respect to Online Information and Database Access or Retrieval services (covered by Section 14 of IGST Act, 2017) or actionable claims (covered by Section 14A of IGST Act, 2017).

5. Identical Issues Across States: Subject to satisfaction of President, cases involving identical question of law pending before two or more State Benches (In this case, the filing will be before State Bench only and then the cases may be transferred to Principal Bench on application made to the Principal bench)

Matters Under State Bench Jurisdiction: All appeals that are not to be filed before the Principal Bench have to be filed before the respective State Bench. The issues could include the following (illustrative list):

• Input Tax Credit (“ITC”) denial or reversal
• Classification of goods or services
• Registration issues
• Refund claims and denials
• Transitional issues
• Returns mismatch and reconciliation
• Exemption notification interpretation
• Non-payment of GST demands
• E-way bill related issues
• Valuation disputes

Step 2: Consider the geographic location of the First Appellate Authority Location

For appeal to be filed before the State Bench (i.e., for the cases which are not to be filed before the Principal Bench), the jurisdictional bench would be the one having jurisdiction over the area where the first appellate Authority is located.

In case a common Order-in-Original has been filed against multiple Orders-in-original, then multiple appeals will need to be filed. However, all such appeals will be filed before the State bench in whose jurisdiction, the Appellate Authority is situated.

Geographic Mapping of State Benches

Once State Bench jurisdiction applies, the correct bench is determined based on the location of the first appellate authority, mapped zone-wise as set out below.

1. North:

• Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh (in Srinagar & Jammu)
• Punjab and Chandigarh (in Chandigarh & Jalandhar)
• Haryana (in Gurugram & Hisar)
• Uttarakhand (in Dehradun)
• Delhi (in Delhi)
• Uttar Pradesh (in Lucknow, Prayagraj, Varanasi, Ghaziabad & Agra)
• Rajasthan (in Jaipur & Jodhpur)
• Himachal Pradesh (in Shimla)

1. East:

• West Bengal, Sikkim & Andaman and Nicobar Islands (in Kolkata)
• Bihar (in Patna)
• Jharkhand (in Ranchi)
• Odisha (in Cuttack)

1. Northeast:

• Arunachal Pradesh, Assam, Manipur, and Meghalaya (in Guwahati)
• Mizoram (in Aizawal) – Aizawal has circuit bench
• Nagaland (in Kohima) – Kohima has circuit bench
• Tripura (in Agartala) – Agartala has circuit bench

1. West:

• Gujarat (in Ahemdabad, Suraj and Rajkot)
• Dadra and Nagar Haveli and Daman and Diu (in Surat)
• Maharashtra (in Mumbai, Thane, Pune, Nagpur, Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar )
• Goa (Panaji) – Panaji has Circuit Bench

1. Central:

• Madhya Pradesh (in Bhopal)
• Chhattisgarh (in Raipur)

1. South:

• Telangana (in Hyderabad)
• Andhra Pradesh (in Vijayawada and Visakhapatnam)
• Karnataka (in Bengaluru)
• Tamil Nadu (in Chennai, Coimbatore and Madurai)
• Puducherry (in Puducherry) - Puducherry has circuit bench
• Kerala (in Ernakulam and Thiruvananthapuram)
• Lakshadweep (in Ernakulam)

Step 3: Determine Bench Composition (Single Member Bench vs Division Bench)

After determining the geographic jurisdiction, the nature and quantum of your case determine if your appeal will be heard by a Single Member bench or a Division Bench. :

1. The appeal will be filed before Single Member Bench if:

• Aggregate amount of tax, ITC, fine, fee and penalty does not exceed Rs. 50 lakhs

AND

• No question of law is involved

1. The appeal will be filed before Division Bench if

• Aggregate amount of tax, ITC, fine, fee and penalty exceeds Rs. 50 lakhs

OR

• The matter involves question of law

Practical Tips for Jurisdiction Determination:

Review the First Appellate Order Carefully

The order will mention:

• Authority name and designation
• Office location
• Jurisdiction details

What Happens If You File in Wrong Jurisdiction?

Following could be the likely issues, if the appeal is filed before wrong jurisdiction:

• Rejection of Appeal: Registrar may reject appeal at admission stage
• Transfer Order: Bench may transfer case to correct bench (causes delay in deciding the appeal)
• Limitation Issues: Time spent in wrong forum may not be excluded
• Additional Costs: Fresh filing fees and representation costs

Conclusion

Accurate jurisdiction determination is the foundation of a successful GSTAT appeal. Take time to analyze your case, identify the correct bench, and file in the right forum. When in doubt, consult an experienced GST counsel to avoid costly jurisdictional errors.

**Disclaimer:** Jurisdiction determination can be complex and fact-specific. This guide provides general information and should not be considered legal advice. Always consult qualified legal professionals for your specific case. Jurisdictional rules are subject to amendments and notifications issued by the GST Council and Government of India. 

***

 **Keywords:** GSTAT jurisdiction, Principal Bench New Delhi, State Bench, circuit bench, place of supply jurisdiction, ISD jurisdiction, GST appeals, Section 109 CGST Act